The classic problem: a scooped, gigantic bedroom tone that disappears the second the band kicks in. The reason is almost always the same — scooped mids. The midrange is exactly where a guitar lives in a mix.
Almost always scooped mids. The midrange is where a guitar sits in a mix; with mids near zero the bass and cymbals swallow you. Push mids to 5–7, cut some low end for the bassist, and use presence for cut.